Editorial Review Product Description
Inside its glass dome the One State is a place of mathematical precision, a community where everything belongs to everyone, and integrity, clarity, and unerring loyalty reign over all. D-503, Builder of the Integral, is an honest Cipher, ashamed of the hairy hands that link him to a barbaric ancestry. And yet he is tormented by the figure v-1, that impenetrable x, the legacy that makes him lust, imagine, that has given him a soul. Consumed by his sickness and obsessed with the mysterious I-330, he escapes outside the Wall, to where the humans are wild, the land is green, and plots to overthrow The Benefactor and return his civilization to natural chaos are rampant. Only The Operation can return order to the perfect world, and allow reason to win. ... Read more Customer Reviews (118)
The Kindle version is poorly done
"We" is an incredible novel, but I am really disappointed with the Kindle edition. There are two small things that are really annoying:
1. The chapter subtitles do not have "returns" where it should. For example, chapter 1 has a subtitle:
"Announcement
The Wisest of Lines
An Epic Poem"
But in the Kindle version, we have "Announcement The Wisest of Lines An Epic Poem" which is incredibly misleading.
2. The text seems like an OCR some times. One of the main characters, I-330, is sometimes refered as 1-330 (yes, this typo appears many times, using the letter I and the number 1, which can cause confusion since all character names are letters+numbers).
The funny is that these errors do not exist in the same paper edition, which I also have. I know: they are all small issues, but it is unacceptable to pay this price for something with such problems.
Amazon really should take a little bit more care with its Kindle products (I know that the problem probably occurred by the publisher, while converting the original text).
I would rate 4 stars if there was no problems with the kindle edition. The text is a little bit less enjoyable than Huxley and Orwell, although we can really easily see how the other two were _heavily_ influenced by Zamyatin.
Excellent literature!
This is an amazing piece of literature and a great translation by Brown.Zamyatin is an amazing writer and well worth your time.
If you enjoy Ayn Rand or George Orwell, you'll really enjoy this book.
This could be two stars, or it could be four!
Quite an interesting tale.If you don't know already, this is the first official dystopian novel, written in the early 20th century.After reading it, I can't say I wholeheartedly recommend it, but then I can't really dismiss it either.It's definitely worth reading, but there are some glaring problems with the story/storytelling that drag the book down; but then there are impressive parts to the story/storytelling as well.
The futuristic civilization of "We" begins in the days preceding the launch of a spacecraft called the INTEGRAL.Any societies encountered by the INTEGRAL and its crew are to, in a few words, be bent to the will of the society that launched the spacecraft.The story is told from the perspective of the main character, the lead engineer/designer of the INTEGRAL.He is keeping a journal to share with encountered societies so that they can better understand and appreciate his own civilization and why it's so great.But then things start happening (he meets a mysterious woman), things that he might not want to put in his journal, but does anyway.
Now the translator of the book points out in the introduction that there is a whole "Buck Rogers" comics feel to the book, and he's right.Airships and rockets with people in helmets, a glass city with glass buildings, a sense of scientific order: all good stuff.
There's also the creepy Benefactor, a big humanoid with huge iron fists who is the "leader" of the futuristic society.(You don't, by the way, ever find out if the Benefactor is, in fact, human or why he has huge iron fists.)He's good to have, along with the Glass Bell (a torture device).And let's not forget the execution stadium with the human disintegrator (I can't remember what it's called, but it does have a name).Good dystopian accoutrements.
Sex tickets are also a part of the society, where you essentially get to sleep with whomever you want providing you make a reservation and get a ticket for the person you're interested in.That's fine, too.
The problems with "We" stem from the following:
1) The intermittent stream of consciousness storytelling style, which is fine except that you're not really sure what's going on or what happened at some points in the story.Leads to unnecessary confusion.
2) The Old House, which seems to be an artless museum of sorts--in the form of an old apartment building--where revolutionaries hide out and do whatever they want, but it seems that the security forces of the civilization would have to be inept to not know about it or have bulldozed it.
3) The glass buildings.You're never quite sure if they're made out of huge glass blocks or if they're just walled with glass.The author could have made this very clear, yet never did.
4) At points in the story, the main character notices "some guy" and the author sort of takes it for granted that you know who he's talking about, but the guy could've been sparsely described in a stream of consciousness section, leaving unsure as to who the guy is.This comes up a lot with the person that follows the main character, a described as having an "S" shape.
5) The society lacks detail.While "1984" and "Brave New World" are comparatively designed down to the last bolt, the society in "We"--which attempts to be as efficient and robotic as possible--doesn't come across as believable.I mean, it's supposed to be regimented and structured, yet the opaque Old House (mentioned above) exists in the glass-walled city of glass buildings.And where's the Benefactor come from?What's his story/origin?
If you've seen "Equilibrium," you might understand better.There's supposedly this oppressive, highly organized dystopian society that watches everyone, yet behind every rock, bush and wall there's a revolutionary member camped out, ready to take it all down."Here we are, brutish security force, but you'll never find us!"
Overall, a good story with some "communication" problems and a not-entirely-fleshed-out society.I did like the ending, which is, of course, dystopian (the ending, that is, not my liking of it).
Best that you read it and decide for yourself how good it is.I'd be interested in your comments.(In fact, I've never had so many questions about a book after I finished it as I had when I finished this one.)
Dystopia
Considered to be the original in the mold of the dystopia novel, it is easy to see how "We" influenced many other books.Still, there is something unique about this book, which sets it apart from the others.Some have even labeled the book to be a satire, as many of the themes are based on events in Zamyatin's life in early 20th Century Russia.Yet the novel is likely to leave the reader move disturbed than humored.
D-503 lives an exemplary life in One State.He is the designer of the Integral, a spaceship designed to spread One State's brand of government to other planets in much the same way communism was once feared to spread.Yet D-503 spends a good deal of time with his main love interest O-90 and the State poet R-13 referring to their relationship as a triangle. This is because intimate relations are can be shared freely among numbers as long as the partnership is registered and regulated by One State.
The temptress I-330 brings this complacency to an end. She is in league with the rebellious Mephi and skews D-503's concept of One State.D-503 feels emotions he should not feel, and is even diagnosed as developing a soul.His infatuation parallels with breaks in the orderly life of One State that bring Benefactor to recommend a procedure that is certain to end the rebellious nature in all numbers.
Though the novel ends with a sense of resolution, the read is left to determine what may happen beyond these 225 pages.I liked the fact that the conclusion of the story may not be a final ending.
Being written initially in Russian, I can not help but wonder how this novel would read in Russian.Often, I found the wording to be somewhat clumsy.However, this did not take away from my overall enjoyment of the book.
A Bleak, Claustrophobic Vision of the Future
Banned in the Soviet Union until the late 80s, this dystopic vision served as a blueprint for Orwell's Nineteen Eighty-Four.The book takes place in the future, where mankind lives in the "perfect" society of OneState.No one has names, everyone is a "Number".All of the buildings, including furniture are made of transparent glass, the better for the Guardians to keep an eye on everyone.Everything is regulated, from the work day, to meals (food is made from petroleum) to sexual relations (which require a pink ticket).Every Number has a shaven head and wears a uniform with a badge that contains a clock.Any dissent is punishable by death, meted out by the Benefactor, the ruler of OneState.
The story is told by D-503, a mathematician and engineer, who is building the Integral, a spacecraft designed for the sole purpose of taking OneState's message and control to whatever alien lifeforms might exist.D-503 is happy and content to live and serve in OneState, at least until he meets I-330, a mysterious woman who's part of an underground movement seeking to overthrow OneState's oppressive government.As the story progresses, D-503 finds himself questioning himself and his beliefs as he becomes more deeply involved with I-330.
The book is written as a series of D-503's journal entries and the writing style Zamyatin employs serves to reinforce that construct.In this halting, almost primitive style, the reader is presented with D-503's moral dilemmas, his fear, his burgeoning love, and spark of individuality against the backdrop of enforced conformity.There's a feeling of claustrophobia that permeates this novel, which far outweighs any of the hokier science-fiction elements of the story.Not as sharp as 1984 or Brave New World, but well worth a read.
... Read more
|