Editorial Review Product Description Zahn presents "a fast-paced adventure yarn (that) brings together exploration for new stars, racial tensions, Third World activism and a group of vanished aliens with a high-tech twist."--United Press International. Reissue. ... Read more Customer Reviews (8)
Boring,Cardboard Characters,UN Hating Author
This novel read like it was written back in the 50's instead of the 80's. Like a B-grade SciFi movie and not a very good one at that. The author cannot seem to flesh out the characters and relies upon stereotypes for each one. His laughable attempt at making any of the female characters seem realistic falls flat totally. Honestly I don't see why anyone would give this story anything more than one star. This is supposed to be a first contact scenario with not one or two but multiple races but the humans just look at it as some pesky aliens that have to be dealt with instead. Sort of like how the main military jerk, I mean commander looks upon the Latino population there. The author loves to flag wave and Americanize everything. I guess just us Americans are going to populate the universe. Too many flaws to list them all but the story just leads to one amazingly bad ending after all the build up. NOT recommended.
"An Earth-type world complete with water and a breathable atmosphere and no metals?That's absurd!"
"An Earth-type world complete with water and a breathable atmosphere and no metals?That's absurd!"
I was reading another book, but I got so tired of the issues I had with that book, I had to take a break.Plus, I got to meet Timothy Zahn on January 8th, so I was pumped to finish reading my almost complete collection of Timothy Zahn published works!
Humankind (to be politically correct) has finally developed the capacity to travel faster than light.They set upon to leave an overpopulated, overmined Earth (in typical fashion for scifi books written in this era) only to find that the rest of the galaxy is populated by superior aliens.The only world left is Astra, a world strangely without any trace metals.The United Nations decide that the Americans should spearhead the colonization.The Americans in turn assign Colonel Llyod Meredith to oversee Astra's development...and to deal with disputes between the colonists (led by Cristobal Perez) and the military.But things get strange when the planet seems to suck away all metal and produce a six centimeter in diameter cable.Now, all the surrounding aliens want a piece, Astra is a hotspot in the conflict between the United Nations and the United States, and Meredith might lose his tenuous hold on the citizens of Astra.
I Like:
Timothy Zahn is my absolute favorite writer for many reasons.This book showcases one of the biggest reasons: his ability to combine a cool, interesting story with enough realism to make you feel like you are there.
The story of Spinneret is slightly different than most scifi I've read.Space has already been colonized until the only planet left is the dud, the one no one wants.Earth takes it only because it may be the only one they get; then the Americans (those chosen to spearhead the colonization) begin to pour money into what could easily be a money pit.Now, granted, I haven't read all scifi books in print, but I have read a few, and this unique concept intrigued me.
The idea of the planet using metal from things like shelves to plants' soil was really interesting as well, along with the planet making a strand of the strangest material ever.The properties of the material were described in such a way, it was obvious Timothy Zahn was familiar with some basic material science and metal's properties.Throughout the book, Zahn uses scientific terms fairly accurately and with knowledge, that makes the geek in me squee with joy.The scientific technology shows its age (with cassettes to hold data and other 80's-ish gadgets), but oddly enough, it doesn't take away from the story at all.
I found it very easy to get sucked into the book.It has an easy writing style, a quick pace, exciting events, and an intriguing premise.Zahn doesn't hang around, chewing the fat, or leaving the reader to wonder when the story will resume.The story is always going.Everything leads to the final scene, which, while short, is more than adequate.
I know it will sound odd, but the conclusion was definitely satisfying.So many books have a combination of hastily done, overly simplistic, overly optimistic, or childish, but this book's ending makes sense.It has a positive outlook, for sure, but there aren't pages of explaining the last 100 pages for the reader, no "sudden revelations", no "happily ever afters".It was, in all sense of the word, good.
I Didn't Like:
While I adore Zahn, I am not oblivious to his faults, and I felt there were more than a few weak points in this novel.
The characters of Spinneret felt very bland and interchangeable.The major characters (Colonel Meredith, Carmen Olivero, Cristobal Perez, and Dr. Peter Hafner) didn't really feel much different from the other, even though each one comes from different circumstances or backgrounds.Colonel Meredith knew more about geology and other "science-y" stuff than I would have expected from an army officer (even one who is in command of a scientific base like Astra); Olivero miraculously knew how to fly even though she wasn't military (which seemed odd as her job was mostly data crunching); Perez seemed to have one job and that was colony troublemaker, yet was able to figure out how to open the door when Dr. Hafner and Colonel Meredith could not (though you could suppose, since the answer was not complicated, that sometimes "smart" people overthink a problem); and Dr. Hafner felt a bit too much like your stereotypical scientist.In fact, each and every one of the characters knew way more about science than they should (other than Dr. Hafner).And in the end, all become sudden astrogeologists.Overall, I really didn't feel like I got into any of the characters' heads nor could adequately sympathize--no, distinguish--one from another.
Another distracting element was the use of "Um".A character (most frequently, I noticed, Colonel Meredith) would begin a sentence with this word like in the following passage: "Um...Feels awfully smooth for something that's been buried this long."This dialogue feels awkward.I wouldn't say "Um" in this situation; probably "Hm" but not "Um"."Um" always sounds like you are unsure of yourself or gathering your thoughts, but not being thoughtful (which is, I thought, what Colonel Meredith was feeling).
Some of the events are far too easily maneuvered.Colonel Meredith will conveniently let Carmen do *this*.Perez will say *something* that Colonel Meredith will (grudgingly) agree to.Dr. Hafner happens to come to the (correct) conclusion about *that*.I know why it was done, but it still was a little obvious and not always necessary.
Dialogue/Sexual Situations/Violence:
A few swear words grace the pages, but Zahn avoids them for the most part.However, when he does, sometimes it feels awkward and obvious he is trying to avoid swearing.
None.Whatsoever.
The threat of violence hangs in the air as the alien ships surround Astra.Also, Perez joins in a riot against Colonel Meredith's actions.A few soldiers die in an attempted coup, and when the Spinneret is activated
Overall:
I believe I had tried to read Spinneret some years ago and just couldn't get into it.Well, this time, I did, and it was time well spent.I just wish the characters were a little more distinguishable and unique.Four stars for another enjoyable tale.
Brought to you by:
*C.S. Light*
Unique, Creative, and a great read!
Spinneret is a great read.If you are bored with the similarities of many SciFi plots, find this book! (I say *find* because it is currently out of print, try Amazon Used book section, Zshops, or online auctions, or the library).Zahn takes a totally ridiculous idea and creates a masterpiece.The premise of the story is that man finally makes it out of the solar system in hopes of colonization, only to find out that we are latecomers to the game.All the worlds in our reach have already been divided up between several species.The United Nation's is able to trade for a planet regarded as useless (no natural resources to speak of and crops can not be grown) and the USA (being the wealthiest and most technologically advanced nation) will bear most of the financial burden and administrative responsibilities.This situation is palatable as long as the colony is a money pit.The US Colonel in charge of the colony has orders to do whatever necessary to make the colony self-sufficient as soon as possible.This proves to be a daunting task, as the workers (many from third world countries) are being rallied by a charismatic anti-American and refuse to work until their demands are met.Amid the turmoil, scientists begin to analyze an enigma threatening the lives of all colonists.The crops won't grow.And to make matters worse, everything made of metal seems to be disappearing. Finding the answer to these problems eventually leads to an amazing discovery that makes this new colony one of the most valuable commodities in the known universe; hidden technology from the original inhabitants.Soon all aliens are fighting to be our best friend and suddenly the UN wants to run the show -- and politics reigns supreme!The colonists still can't grow their own food nor protect their new discovery from the more technologically advanced aliens. The workers are up in arms and want a piece of the new found profits, the US and UN are trying to outmaneuver one another for control of the colony, and the amazing discovery has left more questions than answers (what happened to the inventors and what do we do if they come back?). As usual, Zahn creates believable characters and a page turning plot structure, based on a far-fetched idea that he somehow makes believable.I think what I like the best about reading anything by Timothy Zahn is the flow of the story.He has the innate ability to give enough technical details to further the story, without bogging down the reader with constant interruptions.Many authors write in an annoyingly choppy fashion, constantly stopping the flow of the story to explain technical details (especially in SciFi) or in order to set up the next scene.Zahn's works seem to have a continuous flow with constant action and dialog that are pertinent to the overall story. Spinneret is one of my favorites from Timothy Zahn, and I encourage you to go out of your way to find this book, it will be well worth the effort.
Unique, creative, and a great read!
Spinneret is a great read.If you are bored with the similarities of many SciFi plots, find this book! (I say *find* because it is currently out of print, try Amazon Used book section, Zshops, or online auctions, or the library).Zahn takes a totally ridiculous idea and creates a masterpiece.The premise of the story is that man finally makes it out of the solar system in hopes of colonization, only to find out that we are latecomers to the game.All the worlds in our reach have already been divided up between several species.The United Nation's is able to trade for a planet regarded as useless (no natural resources to speak of and crops can not be grown) and the USA (being the wealthiest and most technologically advanced nation) will bear most of the financial burden and administrative responsibilities.This situation is palatable as long as the colony is a money pit.The US Colonel in charge of the colony has orders to do whatever necessary to make the colony self-sufficient as soon as possible.This proves to be a daunting task, as the workers (many from third world countries) are being rallied by a charismatic anti-American and refuse to work until their demands are met.Amid the turmoil, scientists begin to analyze an enigma threatening the lives of all colonists.The crops won't grow.And to make matters worse, everything made of metal seems to be disappearing. Finding the answer to these problems eventually leads to an amazing discovery that makes this new colony one of the most valuable commodities in the known universe; hidden technology from the original inhabitants.Soon all aliens are fighting to be our best friend and suddenly the UN wants to run the show -- and politics reigns supreme!The colonists still can't grow their own food nor protect their new discovery from the more technologically advanced aliens. The workers are up in arms and want a piece of the new found profits, the US and UN are trying to outmaneuver one another for control of the colony, and the amazing discovery has left more questions than answers (what happened to the inventors and what do we do if they come back?). As usual, Zahn creates believable characters and a page turning plot structure, based on a far-fetched idea that he somehow makes believable.I think what I like the best about reading anything by Timothy Zahn is the flow of the story.He has the innate ability to give enough technical details to further the story, without bogging down the reader with constant interruptions.Many authors write in an annoyingly choppy fashion, constantly stopping the flow of the story to explain technical details (especially in SciFi) or in order to set up the next scene.Zahn's works seem to have a continuous flow with constant action and dialog that are pertinent to the overall story. Spinneret is one of my favorites from Timothy Zahn, and I encourage you to go out of your way to find this book, it will be well worth the effort.
Unique, creative, a great read!
Spinneret is a great read.If you are bored with the similarities of many SciFi plots, find this book! (I say *find* because it is currently out of print, try Amazon Used book section, Zshops, or online auctions, or the library).Zahn takes a totally ridiculous idea and creates a masterpiece.The premise of the story is that man finally makes it out of the solar system in hopes of colonization, only to find out that we are latecomers to the game.All the worlds in our reach have already been divided up between several species.The United Nation's is able to trade for a planet regarded as useless (no natural resources to speak of and crops can not be grown) and the USA (being the wealthiest and most technologically advanced nation) will bear most of the financial burden and administrative responsibilities.This situation is palatable as long as the colony is a money pit.The US Colonel in charge of the colony has orders to do whatever necessary to make the colony self-sufficient as soon as possible.This proves to be a daunting task, as the workers (many from third world countries) are being rallied by a charismatic anti-American and refuse to work until their demands are met.Amid the turmoil, scientists begin to analyze an enigma threatening the lives of all colonists.The crops won't grow.And to make matters worse, everything made of metal seems to be disappearing. Finding the answer to these problems eventually leads to an amazing discovery that makes this new colony one of the most valuable commodities in the known universe; hidden technology from the original inhabitants.Soon all aliens are fighting to be our best friend and suddenly the UN wants to run the show -- and politics reigns supreme!The colonists still can't grow their own food nor protect their new discovery from the more technologically advanced aliens. The workers are up in arms and want a piece of the new found profits, the US and UN are trying to outmaneuver one another for control of the colony, and the amazing discovery has left more questions than answers (what happened to the inventors and what do we do if they come back?). As usual, Zahn creates believable characters and a page turning plot structure, based on a far-fetched idea that he somehow makes believable.I think what I like the best about reading anything by Timothy Zahn is the flow of the story.He has the innate ability to give enough technical details to further the story, without bogging down the reader with constant interruptions.Many authors write in an annoyingly choppy fashion, constantly stopping the flow of the story to explain technical details (especially in SciFi) or in order to set up the next scene.Zahn's works seem to have a continuous flow with constant action and dialog that are pertinent to the overall story. Spinneret is one of my favorites from Timothy Zahn, and I encourage you to go out of your way to find this book, it will be well worth the effort.
... Read more |