Editorial Review Product Description Clipped by a speeding car while crossing the street in Boston+s South End, Reggie Cutter gratefully accepts the help of her attractive upstairs tenant, financial analyst Steven Damelin. Over ice packs, Reggie is surprised to hear that Steven and her late aunt Jo were involved in a -deal+ just before she died, and now Steven wants to get Reggie involved. But before she can hear more, Steven is murdered, and her own apartment door is smeared in blood. Reggie+s used her psychic powers before to help the Boston P. D., but this time she+s a suspect relegated to the sidelines. Will her abilities be strong enough to prove her innocence-and stop a killer who+s marked her as his next victim? ... Read more Customer Reviews (5)
Annoying main character and inacurate description of Boston
Another book chosen at random from the library to read on the T to and from work. The mystery itself was interestingly plotted, but everything surrounding it is the reason for my low rating.
Ms. Tishy has clearly researched, but never been a resident of, Boston. The city is written to be a major character in the book, with many references to local streets and neighborhoods. However, anything that can't be found on a tourist web site or census map is wrong. [After writing this, I read a different author bio than is included on the book jacket; it appears she lived in Boston for twenty years. This just makes the characterizations of the city and its residents all the more egregious and hateful.]
The problems with setting characterization are too many to list and start on page 2; after the main character is hit by a car, her upstairs tenant tries to convince her it was her fault because she didn't cross at the walk. Anyone who has spent a half a day in the city will tell you that locals - drivers and pedestrians alike - have only a vague idea what the white stripes in the road mean. Any street that is not a highway can and will be crossed at any point. Crosswalks just mean that pedestrians are more likely to swear at the cars that won't stop for them.
Reggie Cutter, our "heroine," is an idiot and a racist. She doesn't solve the case through intelligence or even good use of her psychic powers, but dumb luck. People tell her things because she is very annoying and they want her to leave. To a certain amount the racism in the book could be overlooked as a character flaw of the Reggie's, but then is becomes clear the problem is with the author herself.
The scene where the author's prejudices and shoddy research first bleed into the story happens fairly early. After someone is killed in Reggie's building, the killer paints something in an Asian language on her door in blood. She takes some photos and brings them to Chinatown to see if anyone can translate. Although she tries several stores she can't find a single person working there who can speak English well enough for her to explain what she is asking for. That is simply impossible. Sure, many stores may have one or two employees who's grasp on English is minimal, but the vast majority of stores are run by families that have lived in America for many generations and are fully bi-lingual. The whole exchange was insulting to read.
Another instance occurs when Reggie goes to Mozart St. in Jamaica Plain to talk with a teenager that the deceased had been mentoring. Because his last name is Spanish and he lives on a predominantly Hispanic block, she buys a Spanish phase book and never even attempts to speak English to his neighbors. In so doing, she stumbles upon a very good way of ensuring that no one in a Hispanic neighborhood will speak with you: be a busy-body white woman in your 50's shouting "Hola! Hola!" up at people windows. They speak English just fine, but are now pissed off because you obviously think they are too stupid to learn. Again, like the Chinatown scene, just because someone has retained the language and traditions of their ancestors doesn't mean that they are a recent immigrant and/or ignorant of the predominant language of the country they live in.
In closing the whole book was insulting on several levels and I only finished it because the book I was waiting on wasn't yet available.
I look forward to another in the series but
I hope the author does a better job managing the characters. The ending felt tacked-on; yes, we learned the killer's identity, but in a rather abrupt manner. Felt as though a timer had gone off, sort of the end of an exam: "Fingers off the keyboard, pass your work forward to your publisher."
Psychic absurdity
Life can be rough for a psychic when her powers fail, as they do big-time one day for Reggie Cutter.She has no forewarning of the speeding car which leaves her sprawling, bruised on the road.And though the tenant in her apartment house comes rushing out, he isn't much help.He insists she was jaywalking, which somehow convinces her that the hit and run really wasn't really a hit and run.But that's just the beginning of a bad day.That evening, blood drips down by the radiator in her apartment from the tenant's rooms above and--you've guessed it!--he's been murdered . . . killed with an electric drill and pinned to the floor with a nail gun.In addition, a strange calligraphic figure has been written in blood on Reggie's door. All of this leaves her determined to find out who the killer/artist is but her psychic powers do little to help either her or the police.ALL IN ONE PIECE is about Reggie's dogged and frequently bruised pursuit of the perpetrator among a host of suspects.Tishy manages to keep up a suspenseful atmosphere while providing an intriguing protagonist--one who manages to bumble along to a final and somewhat unbelievable solution to both the crime and the art work.
A good read!
Reggie Cutter's new upstairs tenant, Steven Danelin, comes to her rescue when she is hit by a car in front of her house. He wants to tell her about a financial deal he was working on with Reggie's late Aunt Jo, but never gets the chance as he is found murdered in his apartment the next morning.
Reggie has worked with the police before, but her psychic abilities are not requested for this case because the lead detective considers her a suspect. Reggie starts investigating on her own to find out if she is in danger from the killer--and to clear her name.
The first person, present tense narrative makes it difficult for us to get to know the secondary characters as real people since we only learn about them through their conversations with Reggie--though this has improved since the first book in this series.
Reggie is a compassionate person, despite being unable to let go of the pampered life she led before her divorce. Even though she is relatively new in cultivating her psychic abilities, she intends to use them to help people.
Armchair Interviews says: We like Reggie for that and want her to succeed and look forward to more in this series.
charming amateur sleuth mystery
After divorcing her wealthy husband and losing much of her income, psychic Reggie Cutter moves into the townhouse she inherited from her aunt Jo in Boston's South End.Jo was a psychic who helped the police on many cases and Reggie is following in her footsteps.Her life takes a dangerous twist when she gets hit by a car.Her upstairs tenant Steven Damelin sees the incident and believes it was t an accident not someone deliberately trying to kill her.After getting her fixed up Stephen talks about a deal that Jo was going to invest in and ask Reggie if she is interested.She puts him off.
That night she hears strange noises and the next morning she sees blood dripping from Steve's apartment into hers; she opens his door and sees him lying on his floor, the victim of a gruesome murder.Since she is involved the police don't want her working the case.She intends to listen to them but she has a vision of Steve in water and a piece of wood hitting him.She decides to do her own investigation by interviewing plenty of suspects who had reason to kill him, and almost winds up getting killed by a murderer without mercy.
ALL IN ONE PIECE is a charming amateur sleuth mystery with the eccentric cast of characters adding humor to this who-done-it.The protagonist is a down to earth person who thinks of her psychic powers as a tool to be used as one more investigative method while readers will look at her as the kind neighbor next door that everyone likes.Cecelia Tishy has a knack for creating a plausible mystery with a paranormal twist.
Harriet Klausner
... Read more
|