Editorial Review Product Description Bill knew his destiny lay in the stars, but how was he to get there? George Lerner was shipping out for Ganymede to join the fledgling colony, and Bill wanted to go along. But his father would not hear of it -- far too dangerous a mission! Bill finally talked his way aboard the colony ship Mayflower -- and discovered his father was right! ... Read more Customer Reviews (26)
A fun novel that's less exciting than some other Heinlein juveniles
Other reviewers have summarized the plot; I'll simply explain my four star rating.I enjoyed Heinlein's juveniles when I was a teenager, and again upon rereading them in adulthood.Heinlein's juveniles offer an education in science, always written in language us non-scientists can comprehend: in Farmer in the Sky, the reader learns lessons of physics, agronomy, ecology, even "population bionomics" (although Heinlein's take on the inevitability of population growth outpacing food supplies might not be well grounded in science, at least as applied to human populations).At least equally interesting, I think, are the Heinlein values that shine through in his novels, and this one is no exception:his distrust of government and bureaucratic institutions; his fierce belief in individualism, coupled with a corresponding belief in the need for individuals to work cooperatively as friends and neighbors and families.And yes, as a one-star (and one-note) reviewer here observed, there's a bit of misogyny in the story, but hey, this is Heinlein, and the novel was written in 1950:his sensibility evolved (somewhat) in later years, and it's a relatively small part of the overall story.
The plot of Farmer in the Sky unfolds a bit more slowly than the stories in some of Heinlein's other juveniles.Frequently mentioned is Bill Lerner's joy in being an Eagle Scout and his love of scouting in general.A shorter version of the book was originally serialized in Boy's Life magazine--perhaps Heinlein included the scouting references to enhance his chance of selling the story, but since they continue to appear (often) in the novel, I suspect Heinlein simply placed great value in scouting.The scouting references don't contribute much to the story (unless you're a real scouting fanatic), but they don't detract from it either.
In short, Farmer in the Sky is fun, educational, but a bit less exciting than some of the other Heinlein juveniles.For the Heinlein completist it's an essential read, but readers seeking the furious action of Starship Troopers might be disappointed.
Early RAH teen novel excellent of the type and time 1950
Farmer in the Sky by Robert A. Heinlein
If you are a devotee of Robert A. Heinlein (1907-88) and enjoy science fiction novels with lucid extrapolations of the near future then "Farmer In The Sky" should be on your "must read" list.
Overpopulation pressures induce the more adventurous, or more reckless families of Earth's teeming cities to apply for homesteads on the Terraformed Jupiter moon Ganymede. As Heinlein would state in another novel (Farnham's Freehold) TNSTAAFL - "Their Not Such Thing As A Free Lunch". Each homesteader-farmer must pledge several years of crops and labor to repay his passage and use of farm tools - the land is free.
Heinlein deftly handles the narrative detailing the fear and uncertainty within the Lerner household as they leave the security of Earth for the life of a pioneer. His descriptions of the homestead activities on an alien world are engrossing.
My only complaint, and a minor one at that, was the introduction of an "alien artifact" to give, I suppose, the story a real 1950's SF zing.
This novel, although written for the teen market in 1950, can be enjoyed by readers of all ages.
Settling a New World
Farmer in the Sky (1950) is the fourth SF novel in the Juvenile Series, following Red Planet.It is set at a time when the moons of Jupiter were being terraformed.Ganymede already had a heat shield to trap solar energy and an atmosphere plant to convert the ice to breathable air.A colony -- with a population of thirty thousand -- had formed around the power station at Leda.
The colonists had been carried to Ganymede in nuclear powered ships.Now the torchship Mayflower is being prepared to carry six thousand immigrants to the Ganymede colony.It will be leaving soon.
In this novel, William (Bill) Lermer is an Eagle Explorer Scout and leader of the Yucca Patrol.His mother Anne had died when he was much younger, but he has been living as a partner of George -- his father -- ever since.If it hadn't been for Bill, George would have staved to death long ago.
Hank Jones is also an Explorer and Eagle Scout in another Patrol.He is impulsive and exertive.
Molly Kenyon is a draftsman in George's office.She has a twelve year old daughter named Peggy.
In this story, Bill is flying home from a trip to the High Sierras with Hank as his co-pilot.Bill doesn't know Hank very well and doesn't like the way that he is behaving.When he reaches home, Bill cooks supper for his Dad and complains about Hank's pushy attitude.
Then George tells Bill that he will be going to Ganymede on the Mayflower, but that Bill will be staying behind.George wants Bill to finish his education before relocating to Ganymede.Bill disagrees and they have a bitter argument.
When Bill returns from a field trip to Antarctica, George show him an application for the voyage made out in Bill's name.Naturally, Bill informs all his friends and acquaintances of the possibility of his going to Ganymede.Then comes the tests, but both of them pass and are accepted as colonists.
Then George breaks the news that he is getting married.Bill is shocked and leaves the room.He can't understand how his Dad could betray Anne.But he remembers how his mother told him to "stand tall" and he manages to interact with Molly and Peggy.But he is by no means friendly.
They take a shuttle out to the Mayflower.After a long wait, the Mayflower powers up and away.Bill had been expecting something worse than the shuttle takeoff, but the interplanetary ship uses only one gee of acceleration.
After sixty days of avoiding boredom -- and a very exciting meteorite strike -- the Mayflower reaches Ganymede orbit.The shuttle ferries the new immigrants down to the surface, where they find confusion and makeshift arrangements. The Mayflower carries many more colonists than previous ships and the settlement is struggling to cope.They have converted community buildings into barracks just to house the newcomers.
This tale relates the efforts of the Lermer family to adjust to a new and uncertain situation.At least there is a settled community already in place, even though the population has suddenly grown by twenty percent.When claims are assigned, George and Bill discover that they have a well established and quite friendly family as neighbors.
Ganymede has a reasonable climate thanks to the heat shield.The ground is sterile outside of the settled areas, but the rocks can be converted to soil through hard and persistent work.Yet Ganymede is a still relatively new environment and contains a few more surprises.
This story is about human interactions and personalities, with only a few minor conflicts.The real fight is with the environment on a newly settled world.Read and enjoy!
Highly recommended for Heinlein fans and for anyone else who enjoys tales of planetary colonization, pioneer societies, and interpersonal relationships.For those who have not previously read this series, the initial volume is Rocket Ship Galileo.
-Arthur W. Jordin
A good science fiction story, but lacks believability
"Farmer in the Sky" is good science fiction and is suitable for teenagers.Heinlein was writing science fiction for 'juveniles' when he wrote this.And, he had a problem.Question: Can I get young readers to make a huge jump to believe in interstellar travel or should I shorten the jump by putting my stories in our solar system?He decided to put many of his juveniles in our solar system.For the time, it wasn't a bad decision, but today's youngsters are brought up on SF interstellar travel.
I picked this book up in the 1950's as an early teenager.I had problems even then in picturing Gandymede as a possible place for colonization.So, I think you should imagine that this is a story about interstellar colonization.
Other than that, this is a pretty good science fiction story. The beginning is terrific. The middle is good.The end is OK but seems contrived.It is OK, the story is good and is enjoyable, but it is not quite up to my standards for Robert Heinlein.
If you are new to Heinlein, I suggest "Space Cadet" or "Podkayne of Mars" as better places to start reading Heinlein.Read this one only after reading two or three other juveniles by Heinlein.
See the Greatest Tree on Ganymede
_Boy's Life_, the official magazine of the Boy Scouts of America, used to publish a lot of science fiction. It has been quite a few years since I have read the magazine regularly, but I suspect that it still does so. Some of the stories that I read in my youth were pretty marginal stuff. I dimly remember a series about some Scouts from the past, present, and future who got in and out of scrapes with a time machine.
On the other hand, _Boy's Life_ published stories by Ray Bradbury, Poul Anderson, James Blish, Arthur C. Clarke, and Robert A. Heinlein. A large portion of _Farmer in the Sky_ (1950) was serialized in _Boy's Life_ as "Satellite Scout" ( Aug., Sept., Oct., Nov. 1950 ). The satellite is a terraformed Ganymede and the Scout is Bill Lermer, a teenager working on completing his Eagle. The novel deals with some elements of Scouting: merit badge lessons in areas like astrogation and alien ecology, conflicts between members, and power politics between different troops.
But it is not exclusively about Scouting. Bill gets sidetracked by other concerns, such as the details of working a five-acre farm and various family emergencies. At the close of the novel, he still hasn't completed his tests for Eagle.
Alexei Panshin , in _Heinlein in Dimension_ (1968), notes that in Heinlein's later novels, he began to present his opinions as "facts" to the artistic detriment of his work. But _Farmer in the Sky_ has real facts-- or at least, realistic detail-- about how a torchship is powered and spun, how Ganymede was terraformed, how you go about farming land that was once all rock, why a certain tree is the most beautiful one on the planet, what a multiple eclipse of Jupiter's moons will look like, and how a political meeting or a ship's mast is run.
As with many of Heinlein's early works, it is the detail that carries the day. This is a juvenile that can readily be read by young and old readers alike. It well deserves a five-star rating.
... Read more
|